HomeOnline TogetherTalk

Online Together

Cookie banners: what the buttons really ask

What are you agreeing to when you press the button on a cookie banner? A plain-English guide to what is essential, what needs your say-so and how to change your mind ↓

Cover illustration: Cookie banners: what the buttons really ask

On the menu

Five facts about cookie banners and your choices.

  • Cookies and similar technologies store or read information on your device.
  • Some are strictly necessary for a service you asked for and do not need your consent.
  • Others, such as those used for advertising measurement, generally need your consent under UK rules.
  • Refusing should be as easy as accepting, and you should be able to change your mind later.

You open a website and, before you can read a word, a box appears asking about cookies. Most of us press whichever button makes it go away. This guide explains what the box is really asking, what the rules say in the UK, and how you can use your choices. It is based on guidance from the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO), the UK’s data protection regulator, and on the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations 2003 (PECR). It is general information; the law in this area is updated from time to time, so the ICO’s pages are the best place to check the latest position.

A cookie is a small file that a website places on your device. It might remember that you are signed in, what is in your basket or your preferred language. Other, similar technologies do the same job, such as local storage in your browser or tracking pixels. The ICO uses the wider phrase "storage and access technologies" to cover them all.

Some are set by the site you are visiting. Others are set by third parties, such as advertising or analytics services, which can follow your activity across different sites.

Under PECR, a website generally has to tell you about the cookies it uses and get your consent before setting them. There is an important exception: cookies that are strictly necessary to provide a service you have asked for do not need consent. Examples are those that keep items in a shopping basket, remember a security setting or let you stay signed in.

Cookies used for advertising, for tracking you between sites or for certain measurement purposes are not strictly necessary in that sense, and so, in general, need your permission. The ICO explains the different categories and the exceptions on its pages, and the rules in this area are being refined, so check there for the current detail.

The ICO’s guidance says that consent must be freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous, and that it must be a clear positive action. That has several practical consequences:

  • Pre-ticked boxes do not count. Silence or scrolling is not consent.
  • You should be told what you are agreeing to, in clear language, before you decide.
  • Refusing should be as easy as accepting. A banner with a prominent Accept button and a hidden or complicated way to say no does not meet that standard.
  • You should be able to change your mind as easily as you gave consent, for example through a link to cookie settings on every page.
  • A website should not make a service worse just because you decline non-essential cookies, where the service does not need them.

4Reading the buttons

You will see a few common patterns. "Accept all" and "Reject all" side by side, with equal prominence, is the clearest. "Manage preferences" or "Settings" opens a panel where you can pick categories, for example necessary, analytics and advertising. If a banner offers only "OK" or "Accept", with no way to refuse, ask whether it is meeting the guidance.

Colour and size are worth noticing. If one button is bright and large and the other is a small grey link, the design is steering you. That is not the same as being given a free choice.

5What happens when you choose

Whatever you pick is usually remembered by a cookie or a similar item, which is a reason the choice itself is considered necessary. If you clear your browser data, the choice may be forgotten and the banner will reappear. That is normal.

If you accept, the site may set the extra cookies straight away. If you reject, it should not. Sites usually have a "cookie settings" link in the footer that lets you review or change your choice.

6Doing more in your browser

You can also manage cookies in your browser settings. Most browsers let you view stored cookies, delete them, block third-party cookies or clear them every time you close the browser. Some also offer privacy modes that do not keep cookies after you finish. The ICO’s guidance for the public explains your options. Bear in mind that blocking all cookies can stop some sites working, for example by preventing you from staying signed in.

7What this site does

Because we write about this topic, it seems fair to say what we do. This site’s banner has equal Accept all and Reject all buttons. It stores only your choice, on your own device, and you can change it at any time through the cookie settings link in the footer. Our cookie policy lists exactly what is stored and why.

8If you think a site is getting it wrong

If a website seems to set non-essential cookies without asking, or makes refusing difficult, you can raise it with the organisation first. If you are still concerned, the ICO takes complaints from the public and explains how to make one. It will not usually resolve an individual dispute, but it uses concerns to decide where to look.

9Quick habits

  • Look for the Reject button before you press Accept.
  • Use the settings link to review choices from time to time.
  • Clear cookies in your browser now and then.
  • Treat a banner that makes refusing hard with suspicion.
  • Remember that essential cookies do not need consent.
General information based on ICO guidance and PECR. The law is updated from time to time, so check the ICO’s pages for the latest position.

Sources and further reading

  1. ICO: Cookies, guidance for the public
  2. ICO: Guidance on the use of storage and access technologies
  3. legislation.gov.uk: Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations 2003
  4. ICO: Make a complaint

Pages checked in November 2026. Rules and thresholds change: the official page always takes priority.

Good to know. This talk is general information. It is not legal, consumer, employment or other professional advice. Common Table Talks does not sell products or services and does not give personalised advice.

Spotted a mistake? Email us. We correct in the open, as set out in how we work.

Symbolic illustration of the publisher

Hosted by

Harry Thomas Brown, independent publisher in Manchester. He chooses the topics, writes the talks and reads every official page they cite.

Keep reading

Other seats at the table