HomeHouse RulesTalk

House Rules

Reading a headline: five clues before you share

What should you check before sharing a headline that has grabbed you? Five clues, thirty seconds and nothing to download. Run the checklist ↓

Cover illustration: Reading a headline: five clues before you share

On the menu

Five clues for reading a headline.

  • Check who produced the claim and whether you can find the original.
  • Look at the date and the place: is it recent, and does it apply to you?
  • Look for the numbers behind a percentage, and what they are a share of.
  • Ask what is missing, such as the comparison, the definition or the other side.

A good headline is built to be shared. It is short, surprising and emotional, and it usually arrives just when you are in the middle of something else. That makes it a poor moment for careful judgement, and a good moment for a checklist. This page gives five clues you can run in about thirty seconds, with examples drawn from the way official statistics are published by bodies such as the Office for National Statistics. It is a general guide to reading, and it does not comment on any particular story.

1Clue one: who is saying it?

Look for the source. Is the claim from an identifiable organisation, a named person or an unnamed "study"? Is the article quoting the original source, or quoting another article that quoted it? The further you are from the original, the more details drop away.

Official bodies publish the original data and explain how it was gathered. The UK Statistics Authority’s Code of Practice for Statistics sets out expectations for how official statistics are produced and shared. If a headline quotes official statistics, you can usually find the release page and read the summary yourself.

2Clue two: when and where?

Check the date. A story from five years ago can be shared again as if it were new. Check the place too: does a figure for one part of the UK, or one town, apply to yours? Many headlines say "Britons" when the data cover England only, or a specific group.

On official release pages, the first paragraph usually states the period covered and the area. It is worth getting into the habit of looking.

3Clue three: how many, out of how many?

A percentage with no numbers behind it is half a fact. "Complaints up by half" could mean two became three. Look for the number of cases and the total they are drawn from. Also look at the time frame: up by half since when?

The ONS publishes methodology notes alongside many of its releases, explaining the definitions used. Two figures that look similar may count different things, such as people who are unemployed and people who claim a particular benefit. Always check what was counted.

4Clue four: is the comparison fair?

Headlines love comparisons: "more than ever", "twice as likely", "the worst in the country". Ask what is being compared with what. Are the groups the same size? Was the measure defined in the same way each time? Is the difference large, or only slightly bigger than the margin of error in a survey?

Also be careful about causes. If a headline says that one thing "leads to" another, check whether the article gives evidence for the link or merely notes that the two go together.

5Clue five: what is missing?

The last clue is the hardest, because you are looking for something that is not there. Does the article give the other side? Is there a quote from the body being criticised? Does it say what the figures leave out, such as people who did not respond to a survey? Does it explain why the change happened, or only that it did?

Sometimes what is missing is context. A rise from a low base can look dramatic, and a fall from a very high one can look small. Context is not a trick; it is part of the story.

6The thirty-second version

  1. Who? Find the original source.
  2. When and where? Check the date and area.
  3. How many? Find the numbers behind the percentage.
  4. Compared with what? Check the comparison is fair.
  5. What’s missing? Look for context and the other side.

7What to do if you are not sure

You have three choices. Do not share. Share with a note saying what you do not know, such as "I haven’t been able to check the source". Or look it up, which usually means a short search for the original release. The kindest thing you can do for friends and family is to pass on things you have checked.

8Check yourself, too

We are not exempt. Every piece on this site ends with a list of sources, and our "how we work" page explains how we handle corrections. If you think a headline of ours falls short of the standards in this checklist, tell us.

9Emotional headlines

Be most careful when a headline makes you angry, frightened or delighted. Those are the feelings that make us share quickly. A short pause is often enough. Close the tab, make a cup of tea and look again.

10A short worked example

Suppose you read that "landlords must protect your deposit within thirty days". Before repeating it, you would ask which nation the page covers, check the date and look for the equivalent rule where you live. You might find that the time limit, the schemes and the penalties differ. That small act of checking is the whole habit in action.

11Where to practise

Choose a recent headline from any source and run the five clues. Then open an ONS release page and see how the same kind of figure is presented there, with its definitions, dates and notes. After a few goes, the questions become habit.

General guide to reading, not a comment on any particular report. ONS pages are cited as examples of how official statistics are presented.

Sources and further reading

  1. Office for National Statistics
  2. ONS: Methodology, topics and statistical concepts
  3. Code of Practice for Statistics
  4. ICO: Information for the public

Pages checked in November 2026. Rules and thresholds change: the official page always takes priority.

Good to know. This talk is general information. It is not legal, consumer, employment or other professional advice. Common Table Talks does not sell products or services and does not give personalised advice.

Spotted a mistake? Email us. We correct in the open, as set out in how we work.

Symbolic illustration of the publisher

Hosted by

Harry Thomas Brown, independent publisher in Manchester. He chooses the topics, writes the talks and reads every official page they cite.

Keep reading

Other seats at the table